Matthew McConaughey’s greatest onscreen successes seem to come when he is able to blend his laid-back, rakish charisma with a more haunted (or haunting) inner depth. Otherwise, he’s by and large wasted on slacker stereotypes and short-shrifted in sub-par romantic comedies. His embrace of more dramatic fare sometime around 2012 suddenly turned his reputation around — he was invited to join the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, and he started to be nominated for awards other than Golden Raspberries. But will his legitimacy stick? This video traces, in years, roles, and Rotten Tomatoes ratings, the career of Hollywood’s perhaps least-well-utilized actor.