The first time Jared Leto stole our hearts was over 30 years ago as the brooding, flannel-clad, and illiterate Jordan Catalano on My So-Called Life (which also starred Claire Danes). Since then, he’s worked with legendary directors, won an Academy Award, and played the most infamous Batman villain of all time. Plus, he’s gone “platinum” twice: Once as a styling choice for his role in David Fincher’s cult classic Fight Club, and again for selling a million records as the frontman for rock band Thirty Seconds to Mars! Leto is an A-lister whether onscreen or on the mic —how many other celebrities can claim the same? As we prepare to see him as a replicant creator in Blade Runner 2049, we take a look back at a career full of unexpected transformations.