Sudden Manhattan
1996
Reviews
Manhattan is the perfect setting for a story based on blurred lines between fantasy and reality, comedy and tragedy. I was really impressed with the originality of the script, and how well the whole thing was executed--especially considering it was Shelley's first feature. It made me want to see more films by female writer/directors, and especially ones about women in their twenties.
The scene in the movie where Donna calls her mother for help reminded me of a scene exactly like that in Maren Ade's THE FOREST FOR THE TREES. That movie was also written and directed by a young woman, I think a first feature, and came to mind as an interesting comparison. In both films, the protagonist is lonely in a city. It's a struggle for both, in very different ways, and when things are at their worst they do that childlike thing--they call mom. It was an understated scene that really resonated in both films.
In the interview on Keyframe, "At any given moment," Shelley says she likes directors with a clear vision, and that comes through in Sudden Manhattan. When Shelley made it, she really "took action," as her character tries to do so many times in the film.

Subscribe today.